Ranked Results

Default weights - scroll up to customise

What the review covers — America's Test Kitchen

Key points from America's Test Kitchen’s review, tasted from 5 makers — plus the full video below.

America’s Test Kitchen tasted ice cream from 5 makers — comparing blade (Ninja CREAMi), canister (Cuisinart) and self-refrigerating (Whynter) styles.
The theme: each style trades convenience for texture and price.
The point: canister models are cheap but need a pre-frozen bowl; compressor models churn anytime.
The takeaway: Cuisinart canister for value; a compressor model if you make ice cream often.

Source: America's Test Kitchen (video). Points summarized from the review; see the video for full detail.

Every RealRankly ranking is scored 0–100 on 8 independent criteria, and no company can pay to change a score. Use the weight sliders above to reweight the criteria to your own priorities. How we rank →

More videos on this topic

TOP 5 Best Ice Cream Makers 2025
TOP 5 Best Ice Cream Makers 2025
Product Guide
Watch This BEFORE You Buy the Ninja Swirl!
Watch This BEFORE You Buy the Ninja Swirl!
Logan Nathanson
Which Ice Cream Maker Is Actually Worth It? I Tested Them All (2026)
Which Ice Cream Maker Is Actually Worth It? I Tested Them All (2026)
Everything Home
Best Ice Cream Maker 2024: Ninja vs. Breville vs. KitchenAid vs. Cuisinart
Best Ice Cream Maker 2024: Ninja vs. Breville vs. KitchenAid vs. Cuisinart
BestReviews

Forum

Was this ranking helpful?
Discussion
Loading discussion…
Add your take